You’ve been laid off from your employer of several years and a few days after the lay off you get a call - “Do you want to come back as an independent contractor?” Sounds great - you get to keep working with a company you are very familiar with, may get a little more freedom in your work and you get to keep income coming in, but this has a lot of implications that go along with it. These implications have grown recently with the Obama Administration cracking down on the misclassification of workers. Please see the below articles that indicate why the Obama Administration is cracking down on misclassified workers and what type of workers qualify as misclassified. Please also see information in our previous blog from May 2009, “Are You a Misclassified Employee” for more information and resources.
The likelihood of a past employee of a company truly qualifying as an independent contractor is highly unlikely. The company had this person classified as an employee for many years and suddenly they’re an independent contractor? - the government is not going to buy that without a lot of other evidence showing this person truly did decide to go independent, especially when there’s plenty of taxes on the line.
If your employer asks you to come back as a contractor through an agency, this is an entirely different matter. This is W-2 contract work, meaning those taxes still get paid to the government through the staffing agency, and there is no reason for the employee to register as their own company or figure out what taxes they owe as an independent contract when tax time comes. This is another situation when staffing agencies come in handy — a staffing agency can payroll the individual. Perhaps the company is wary of bringing someone back as their full time employee during these sticky economic times, but they know someone that they would be very happy to bring back for a few days of work or perhaps on an ongoing basis, to fulfill some of the holes the layoffs left. Payrolling through an agency is a good way to bring this person back, without having to worry that they’ll be the next company the government cracks down on, and it takes stress off of the employees who haven’t had experience with what being a 1099 contractor entails.
http://www.inc.com/news/articles/2010/02/cracking-down-on-contractors.html
http://www.inc.com/magazine/20080901/employee-or-contractor.html